American Idol CHALLENGE !

Heather DeLuca and I are battling it out again in our second annual American Idol Challenge! Here's how it works: Once the Idol contestants were whittled down to 24, Heather and I each selected our Top 12...6 guys...6 gals. Whoever gets the most correct...wins! Heather won last year - but this time I'm out to an early lead. Here's who we've selected!

Paul's Picks
Paris Bennett
Mandisa
Katherine McPhee
Becky O'Donahue - (OUT)
Kellie Pickler
Lisa Tucker

Chris Daughtry
Patrick Hall - (OUT)
Taylor Hicks
Will Makar
Gideon McKinney
Ace Young


HEATHER'S PICKS
Paris Bennett
Katherine McPhee
Becky O'Donahue - (OUT)
Kellie Pickler
Stevie Scott - (OUT)
Lisa Tucker

Bucky Covington
Chris Daughtry
Taylor Hicks
Sway Penala - (OUT)
David Radford - (OUT)
Ace Young